Kuyankha Fr. Nkhani ya a Joseph Iannuzzi pa Fr. Michel Rodrigue, Gawo 1

Akatswiri awiri azaumulungu apadera, Fr. A Joseph Iannuzzi ndi Dr. Mark Miravalle, aperekera poyera malingaliro awo oyipa a Fr. Michel Rodrigue, wansembe wokhala ndi malingaliro abwino, ngakhale mauthenga ake ochokerawa ndi Mulungu ali pakali pano osatsutsidwa ndi Mpingo. (Ndikofunikira kuti Akatolika azindikire kuti, mulimonsemo sizinali ziweruzo za akatswiri azaumulungu izi zomwe atsogoleri achipembedzo amafuna, kapena ziweruzo zawo sizili ndi tanthauzo lililonse.) Kudzudzula koyambirira kwa a Dr. Miravalle - komwe nkhani ino ikufotokoza - kunali adayankha apa ndi Daniel O'Connor, ndi Fr. Nkhani yaposachedwa ya Iannuzzi, mwa zina, mwa Christine Watkins apa. Pansipa mupeza mayankho atsatanetsatane komanso ozolowera waumulungu waku Britain, Peter Bannister, MTh, MPhil, kwa Fr. Nkhani yaposachedwa kwambiri ndi a Joseph Iannuzzi. 

Gawo lalikulu la nkhaniyi lidula ndipo lidayambika (mwina ndi wochita kufunsa, a Sharon Freeman a "Nyumba ya Loreto") kuchokera pachidutswa cha mfundo zabodza zolembedwa ndi anti-papapa yemwe amakhala ku Roma ndipo ali ndi tsamba lawebusayiti. ya mutu, "Kuchokera ku Roma," yomwe, yomwe, ingasokeretse ena, chifukwa malowa alibe chochita ndi utsogoleri wa Tchalitchi. Nkhaniyo imadzichulukitsa pamfundo zina zomwe sizinali zofunikira poyamba, chifukwa zimangoganiza zopanda umboni. Kupititsa patsogolo kwawo, ndiye kuti kuli pachiwopsezo chochepa kwambiri cha calumny.

Fr. Iannuzzi adamaliza kutsutsa kwake komwe a Fr. Michel ndi mawu oti,Mulungu sagwira ntchito motere. ” Zowonadi, cholinga chachikulu cha Fr. Nkhani ya Iannuzzi ikubwereza mawu akuti, kuyambira Fr. Zobvumbulutsidwa zachinsinsi za Michel zili ndi zambiri zomwe sizinawonekere m'mavumbulutso ena omwe avomerezedwa kale, Fr. Vumbulutso la Michel liyenera kukhala labodza. Mwamwayi, Magisterium yatiwuza kale momwe tingawonere malingaliro awa:

 "Zina zonse ziyenera kunyansidwa ndi chidwi cholingaliracho chomwe chimaganiza kuti china chilichonse chatsopano chikuyenera kutsutsidwa kapena kukayikiridwa.”- Wolemekezeka Papa Pius XII, Divino Afflante Spiritu. Kamutu: 47

Tikukupemphani kuti muganizire, mosamala komanso mwapemphero, kusanthula kofunikira kwa Mr. Bannister pansipa, momwe akunena kuti - ngakhale Fr. Nkhani ya Iannuzzi ili ndi malo ovomerezeka komanso nkhawa zomveka - zomwe amawapeza sizolondola ndipo nthawi zina zimapangidwa chifukwa cha kusamvana. Malingaliro a Mr. Bannister athandizadi owerenga kufunafuna chowonadi kuti azindikire kuti Fr. Michel sananene kuti Papa Francis anali ndi chiphunzitso cholakwika; Bambo Fr. Michel sanawonetsepo chilichonse chosokoneza m'maganizo kapena kukhala wabodza lamatenda (ndikuti, moyowo, moyo wa a Fr.Michel ndiutumiki wake zikuwonetsa kukhumudwitsidwa ndi izi); ndi Fr. Maulosi a Michel sali pafupi 'kuposa kale lonse' monga Fr. Iannuzzi amadzinenera kuti ali, ndipo alibe zinthu zovuta zomwe Fr. Iannuzzi akuti amatero. Chofunika kwambiri, a Mr. Bannister akuwonetsa kuti njira yomwe Fr. Iannuzzi nthawi zambiri atadzudzula a Fr. Michel ndiwolakwitsa kwambiri ndipo alibe chifukwa chotsimikiziridwa ndi Tchalitchi chovumbulutsira chinsinsi. 

A Bannister ananenanso kuti, ngakhale munthu sangathe kutsimikizira Fr. Mauthenga a Michel Rodrigue amachokera kwa Mulungu, komabe, ambiri aiwo amangokhala mwamgwirizano (mwachitsanzo, mauthenga ena ochokera kwa olondola ovomerezeka akunena zinthu zomwe Mulungu adamuuza). 

Ngati mwawerenga kale zotsutsa za Fr. Michel, tikukupemphani kuti muwerengenso izi (ndikukhalabe okonzekera Gawo Lachiwiri la Mr. Bannister, pomwe akambirana za kukonzekera machitidwe olimbitsa thupi), pamodzi ndi ena omwe aikidwa pa www.CountdowntotheKingdom.com tsamba la webusayiti, ndipo mwapemphero bweretsani mawu anu.

***

Pofunsa kusiyana pamalingaliro olakwika okhudzana ndi Fr Michel Rodrigue omwe adasindikizidwa posachedwa ndi Prof.Mark Miravalle ndi Bambo Joseph Iannuzzi, ndiloleni ndinene poyambirira kuti olemba onsewa agwira ntchito yofunika kwambiri yokhudzana ndi chinsinsi cha Katolika, chomwe tili nacho ngongole yoyamikira. Kulimbikira komanso kuleza mtima kwa Dr Miravalle ndikulimbikitsa zaumulungu ndikufotokozera pempholo lachisanu Marian Dogma lofotokozedwaku mizimu yaku Amsterdam kwa Ida Peerdeman (1945-1959) ndichitsanzo. Momwemonso ntchito yoyambilira ya Fr Iannuzzi - posachedwapa yatsimikiziridwa ndi zofufuza zambiri za wofufuza waku France Françoise Breynaert - pakupanga eschatology yokhazikitsidwa ndi Patristic yokhoza kuthana ndi aporia yomwe ili mu malingaliro a Augustine amillennial omwe alamulira zamulungu zakumadzulo kwa zaka 1500. Paradigm yotsiriza yomwe ikuwululidwa kuti sikuti imangokangana kwambiri ndi Lemba komanso siyigwirizana ndi mgwirizano waukulu wazovumbulutsidwa zamakono zachinsinsi. Kwa ife monga othandizira ku Kuwerengera ku UfumuKafukufuku wa a Fr Iannuzzi omaliza maphunziro akhala ndipo apitilizabe kukhala gwero lamtengo wapatali pakuyesa kwathu kuzindikira maulosi omwe akufalikira padziko lonse lapansi komanso uthenga wake m'masiku athu ano.

Komanso, ndikufuna kunena kuti Dr Miravalle ndi Fr Iannuzzi ndiwomwe ali ndi ufulu wofotokoza zakukayikira komanso nkhawa zawo pokhudzana ndi vumbulutsidwe lomwe lidafotokozedwa kwa Fr Michel Rodrigue (bola ngati kukumbukiridwa kuti zofalitsa zawo sizabwino Osati zotsatira za kufunsa kwa tchalitchi). Ndizokondweretsa kuti vumbulutsidwe lacinsinsi, ngakhale lovomerezedwa ndi Tchalitchi, silikumawerengera owerenga ake, makamaka anthu m'malo mokhulupirira Mulungu. Zowonadi, ndikumvetsetsa kuti akanakhala atawunikira mozama zochitika za Fr Michel, potengera mtundu wa zonena zake ndi tanthauzo lake ngati zingakhale kuti zidachokera ku vumbulutso lamphamvu.

Posamudziwa Fr Michel Rodrigue panokha, ndilibe njira yotsimikizira kuti izi ndi zoona zomwe akuti adakumana nazo. Sindingathetseretu mwina kuti maakaunti ake atha kukhala ndi zinthu zosokoneza m'maganizo kapena zabodza mwadala. Ngakhale zili choncho, kuthekera konseku kumandidabwitsa kwambiri, popeza zonsezi ziyenera kuti zidapangitsa kuti apatsidwe mwayi wofunsira ntchito pakadali pano, kapena atamuchotsa paudindo monga Rectorship ndi ntchito zophunzitsira mu Studium St Joseph mu Dayosizi ya Amosi, Quebec. Ngakhale Bishop wa komweko a Gilles Lemay akudzilekanitsa ndi mavumbulutso a Fr Michel Rodrigue, kuvomerezedwa kwa dayosizi ya Studium St Joseph sikunathetseredwe, ndipo Gulu la Atumwi la St Benoit-Joseph Labre lomwe Fr Michel ndiye Wamkulu amakhalabe pa dayosiziyi webusaitiyi, ngakhale mutangokhala ngati Association de facto. Komanso, nditaphunzira mosamala ma CD opitilira ma 30 a ma audio omwe anapatsidwa ndi iye m'malo osiyanasiyana ku North America mchaka cha 2018 ndi 2019, komanso zida zomwe zikupezeka m'Chifalansa (zoyankhulana, zapakhomo), sindinamvepo chilichonse chongonena kuti Fr Michel Rodrigue ndi osakhala ndi nzeru zake zonse, kapena kuti ndi wabodza.

Zina mwazinthu zomwe zafotokozedwa munkhani yaposachedwa ndi Fr Iannuzzi ndizofunikira, makamaka zokhudzana ndi gawo lomwe lingakhalepo la kudziwana kale ndi miyambo yachinsinsi yomwe (mosazindikira) ingakhudze "mavumbulutso" omwe akuganiza kuti ndiomwe angakhale "owona" kwa ena mulingo popanda kukhala zipatso za kudzoza kwachindunji mwamphamvu. Ili ndiye vuto lalikulu kwambiri pofufuza zinthu monga zomwe zimapezeka patsamba lino, ndipo Bambo Iannuzzi ali ndi chifukwa chomveka chotsimikizira vuto lomwe lingakhalepo pokhudzana ndi owona nthawi zambiri.

Vutoli la epistemological limakulirakulira zikafika pazochitika zomwe zimachitika kawonedwe komwe wamasomphenya amatulutsa ndemanga zapakamwa osanenapo ngati izi zimachokera pachidziwitso chaumwini kapena kudziwa kwawo zolembedwa za zinsinsi zina zam'mbuyomu kapena zapano. Chifukwa cha kusamvetseka uku, malingaliro athu ndikuyesa kuyesa zomwe owona akuyang'ana pamaziko okhawo pazomwe amapereka mosavomerezeka ngati vumbulutso lakumwamba, makamaka ngati izi zili ndi zinthu monga kuneneratu kwaulosi komwe kumachitika kapena ayi, popeza izi ndizolondola zovomerezeka. Zomwezo zikugwiranso ntchito pamaumboni ovomerezeka monga zochitika zamankhwala zosachiritsika zosatsimikizika, kutsimikizira mwamaubongo kusintha kwa mafunde aubongo panthawi yachisangalalo chachipembedzo, kusala, kudziletsa pazakudya zilizonse kupatula Ukalisitiya, kuzunzidwa kapena kuyesedwa kwamafuta pazifanizo kapena zifanizo, Mosiyana ndi izi, zolemba zaumwini monga zomwe zafotokozedwa ndi a Fr Michel Rodrigue zokhudzana ndi mbiri yachilendo ya moyo wawo sizingatsimikizike kuti ndizowona kapena zonama: palibe amene akukakamizidwa kuzitenga ngati zenizeni, ndipo ndizomveka ngati akuwoneka ngati tingaganize, koma mbiri yachinsinsi yachikhristu imadziwika ndi zinthu zosayembekezereka, ndipo ngati chochitika chachitika kapena ayi sichingadziwike pakuwerengera zomwe zingachitike. 

Chifukwa chovuta kuwerengera umboni waumwini, ziyenera kuvomerezedwa kuti mafunso ovomerezeka atha kufunsidwa okhudzana ndi a Fr Michel Rodrigue omwe pano tilibe mayankho okonzeka. Komabe, zifukwa zingapo zotsutsa mauthenga ndi mawonedwe a Fr Michel Rodrigue atha kutsutsidwa mwachindunji. Zina mwazomwe zalembedwa kale ndi a Christine Watkins ndi a Daniel O'Connor, ndipo ndikuwuza owerenga mayankho omwe adasindikizidwa patsamba lino, kuphatikiza umboni waposachedwa kwambiri woperekedwa kwa Christine ndi membala wotchedwa Apostolic Fraternity of St Benoit -Joseph Labre akuchitira umboni za machiritso achilengedwe.

Nthawi zina, milandu yomwe a Michel Michel amapatsidwa ingawonekere chifukwa chosamvana. Chitsanzo apa ndikutanthauzira kwa Fr Iannuzzi kwamawu a Fr Michel poyerekeza ndi akuti "zolakwika" za Papa Francis. Palibe paliponse mwamauthenga ake omwe ananenapo kuti Papa wakhala akutsogolera chiphunzitso cholakwika: zomwe akuwoneka kuti akutanthauza ndi zolakwika mu ubusa / woyang'anira kuthana ndi mavuto mu Mpingo. Kaya lingaliro lotere la Papa Francis ndi loyenera kapena ayi ndiye lingaliro lamalingaliro, koma sizinganenedwe kuti ndi zabodza pokhudzana ndi kumvetsetsa kwaumulungu kwa Petrine Office. Apa, monga zonenedweratu za Fr Michel, ndi nthawi yokha yomwe inganene.

Nthawi zina, kusamvetsetsana kumayambira mchilankhulo china cha a Fr Michel: ngakhale zili zomveka kuti ena angawone izi ngati zolephera kwa pulofesa waku seminare, zitha kuwoneka ngati zachifundo kuti amuchotse ntchito chifukwa choti zomwe amalankhula m'kamwa makamaka sizikutsutsana ndi chiphunzitso cha Thomistic. Makamaka akamaperekedwa kwa anthu omwe siophunzira komanso chilankhulo chachiwiri momwe mawu ndi kufotokozera bwino kwa a Fr Michel akuwoneka ochepa kwambiri!

Mulingo wofunikira ndi funso la maubale a Papa wabodza okhudzana ndi okana Kristu. Apa Fr Iannuzzi ndiwolondola pofotokoza kuti zikugwirizana kwambiri ndi Malemba ndi Mwambo kuwona Wokana Kristu ngati wandale wosakhulupirira kuti kuli Mulungu. Komabe, pali zifukwa zomveka zokhulupirira kuti Mwana wa Chiwopsezo adzalandidwa ndi Mneneri Wabodza wochokera mkati mwa maulamuliro Achikatolika, ndipo palibe kusowa kochokera komwe kunanenedweratu kubwera kwa Papa wabodza pankhaniyi (onani Saverio Gaeta , La Profezia dei chifukwa cha Papi, ch. 4). Mpatuko wa Tchalitchi cha Katolika pamlingo wapamwamba zingawoneke kukhala njira yokhayo yomwe "chonyansa cha chipululutso" choyimiridwa ndi Chiprotestanti cha Misa, kuchotsa Kukhalapo Kwachikondwerero cha Ukalisitiya potero "nsembe yopanda malire" (cf. Danieli ch. 12), atha kubweretsa. Zonenerazi zitha kuwoneka zoopsa, koma zimapezeka m'magulu ambiri (mwachitsanzo Fr. Stefano Gobbi, Uthenga # 485, Disembala 31, 1992).

Ndizachidziwikire kuti Papa wovomerezeka, wotetezedwa ndi mzimu wosalakwa, sangavomereze kusintha kwakusintha kwamaphunziro komwe kunanenedweratu ndi a Fr Michel ndi ena ambiri. Komabe, zikuwonekeranso kuti kuwuka kwa "Tchalitchi chonyenga" chomwe amatchulidwa ambiri kuyambira pomwe masomphenya a Anne-Catherine Emmerich a 1820s - Tchalitchi chogwirizana ndi Wokana Kristu - si nkhani yongogonjera ndale kukakamizidwa kuchokera kunja, koma zotsatira za ntchito ya Ecclesiastical Freemasonry mkati, momwe Mpanda Wopanda Ungwiro uyenera kuyang'anira Mpando wachifumu wa Peter. Kusankhidwa (kosavomerezeka) kwa Papa wabodza ndizotheka kwambiri pokhudzana ndi momwe izi zitha kuchitidwira. Kwa Fr Michel Rodrigue kuti alankhule za munthu ngati Wokana Kristu m'malo mwa Mneneri Wonyenga atha kutsutsidwa moyenerera kuti ndiwosasamala pankhani yamaphunziro azaumulungu, koma lingaliro lake lonse silachilendo pamiyambo yaulosi.

Mwina wopenya yemwe amadziwika kwambiri kuti amatchula mwachindunji komanso kangapo konse a tsogolo Papa wabodza ndi Pedro Regis ku Anguera, Brazil, omwe mauthenga omwe adalandilidwa kwa zaka zoposa 33 alandila chidwi ndipo adasamalira mosamala ndi archdiocese (werengani Pano; onaninso, mwachitsanzo, kafukufuku wa kutalika kwathunthu Anguera aveva ragione Wolemba Annarita Magri yemwe akufuna kukonza maulosi ambiri a Pedro Regis ndi zochitika zapano mu Church ndi padziko lapansi. Wina ndi Agustin del Divino Corazon ku Colombia, woyambitsa mpingo wa ovomerezedwa ndi a Servants of Represent to the Sacred Hearts, omwe mauthenga awo a Marian omwe adasindikizidwa nawo adapatsidwa Pamodzi Wolemba Diocese wa Lurin:

“Mpando wa St Peter ukhala wopanda munthu: posachedwa muwona Apapa awiri monga nthawi ya Avignon: Papa m'modzi woona komanso wabodza. Musalole kuti mukhale osokonezeka; khalani atcheru ndi osasunthika ku chiphunzitso cholamitsa ndi miyambo. (Maria, maestra de los apostoles de los ultimos tiempos, Januware 9, 2010).

Zina zomwe zimatsutsa Fr Michel zofotokozedwa ndi Dr. Miravalle ndi Fr. Iannuzzi ali ndi mwayi wofunsa zokhudzana ndi mgwirizano wawo womveka. Izi ndizomwe zimachitika pomwe ena amati zomwe Fr. Michel adamuyika pamalo abwino kunja kwa Mwambo; pomwe izi zitha kuwoneka prima facie kukhala momwe ziliri m'mbali zina, kudziwana bwino ndi zolemba zakale zobvomerezedwa ndi tchalitchi kumati zinthu sizinadulidwe motero zouma, komanso kuti momwe zinthu zimapezekera ndizovuta kwambiri kuposa momwe zingawonekere poyang'ana koyamba.

Mafilosofi, zaumulungu ndi mbiriyakale, lingaliro loti nkhani yovumbulutsidwa payokha itha kuchotsedwa mwachidule pachifukwa chakuti "Mulungu samachita izi motere" ndiyotheka kukaikira. Philosophically, chifukwa kuphunzira zolembedwa zachinsinsi zomwe zingachitike kungangotsogolera ku zofotokoza mawu oti zachitika m'mbuyomu, ayi zolemba za chiyani ndikanathera zichitike mtsogolo. Ngakhale njira zina zobwerezabwereza zitha kuzindikirika m'miyoyo ndi zolembedwa za anthu ovomerezeka omwe akuwonetsa kukhalapo kwa "galamala" ya vumbulutso lachinsinsi (kugwiritsa ntchito mawu a Kadinala Christoph Schönborn), palibe chifukwa chomveka chokweza izi kuchuluka kwa mfundo zosakondera (mwachitsanzo, "monga lamulo") zoyang'anira zomwe mungathe zachitika. Mwambiriyakale, munthu aliyense amatembenukira a priori kunena kuti Mulungu sachita mwanjira inayake - mkangano womwe umawoneka pafupipafupi pokhudzana ndi zochitika zachilendo monga zifanizo zolira kapena zifanizo za magazi (magazi) zomwe zimapezeka m'matupi azinsinsi - ndikuti izi zimaika malire osayenerera paulamuliro wa Mulungu , ndilo tanthauzo, mtheradi. Palibe chifukwa chomwe Mulungu amene amapanga “Zinthu zonse zatsopano” (Yesaya 43:19 / Chivumbulutso 21: 5) ziyenera kuletsedwa ngati zomwe zidalipo m'mbuyomu posankha njira kapena zida zaulosi.

Mu gawo lachiwiri la yankho ili, ndiyesetsa kukhazikitsa mfundo yomalizirayi pankhani zingapo komwe ndikukhulupirira kuti zitha kuwonetsedwa kuti, mosiyana ndi malingaliro omwe afotokozedwa mu nkhani ya Fr Iannuzzi, pamenepo ndi zoyambirira m'Malemba ndi Mwambo pazomwe Fr. Michel akhala akunena. Mwina chovuta kwambiri ndi funso lodetsa nkhawa la "ma refuji." Pomwe maulosi onse ofunikira amatsimikizira kuti tanthauzo lenileni la mawu oti "pothawirapo" alidi auzimu (nthawi zambiri limatanthauzira za Hearts of Jesus and Mary), kuwona izi kupatula gawo lirilonse la kukonzekera kwakuthupi ndikulephera kutengera zifukwa zingapo zazikulu magawo omwe amalankhulanso zothandiza, kumene popanda kuwona izi ngati zoyambira kukonzekera zauzimu.

Pakadali pano, ndikufuna kutsiriza ndikugogomezera kuti ntchito yathu yonse Kuwerengera ku Ufumu sikuyimira kapena kugwera pakukhulupirira kwa Fr. Michel Rodrigue, koma makamaka pamgwirizano wamayiko ambiri womwe, pa umboni womwe tili nawo, akuwoneka kuti ndi gawo lake. Ndili mgwirizano uno womwe timayang'ana kwambiri osati mafunso amunthu payekha.

-Peter Wotsutsa, MTH, MPhil