Mhinduro kuna Jimmy Akin - Chikamu 2

by 
Maka Mallett

 

Cherechedza: Kuverenga Chikamu 1 chemhinduro yangu kuna Jimmy Akin, ona pano.

 

Apologist Jimmy Akin weCatholic Answers akaenderera mberi kutsoropodza kwake yeapostolate yeKuverengera kuHumambo ne chinyorwa chechipiri ikozvino.  

Chekutanga, ndinoshuvira kudzokorora manzwiro angu pazasi pemhinduro yangu yekupedzisira kuna VaAkin yekuti, "sezvo nyika yeCatholic iri kuderera ... kubatana muMuviri waKristu kuri kutyisidzirwa kupfuura kare." Izvi zvinoreva kuti, kunyange zvazvo munhu angave akabatirira kutsoropodza nemaonero emumwe muapostora, kuti aende nazvo kumusangano weruzhinji - pasina magwaro akakodzera uye kunzwisisa kana kubvunzana - zvinounza nyonganiso nekuparadzana muMuviri waKristu. Sezvo Catechism yeChechi yeKaturike rinoti:

Kuti udzivise kutonga nekukasira, munhu wese anofanirwa kungwarira kuturikira kusvika pazvinogoneka pfungwa, mazwi nezviito zvemuvakidzani wake nenzira yakanaka

MuKristu wose akanaka anofanira kuva akagadzirira kupa dudziro yakanaka kune zvakataurwa nomumwe pane kuzvishora. Asi kana asingakwanisi kudaro, ngaabvunze kuti mumwe anozvinzwisisa sei. Kana mumwe akanzwisisa zvakaipa, ngaarangwe norudo. Kana izvozvo zvisina kukwana, muKristu ngaaedze nzira dzose dzakakodzera kuti mumwe wacho awane dudziro yakarurama kuti aponeswe. -Katekisimo yeChechi yeKaturike, kwete. 2478

Zvinosuruvarisa, Mr. Akin akasiya nzira iyi (haana kusvika kwandiri kana boka rangu kuti awedzere kujekesa nekukurukurirana), uye inoratidza. Muchidimbu:

• VaAkin vanoramba vachibvunza kuti nzira yekuziva yakavimbika sei paKuverengera nekupa zano kuti 'mvumo yeChechi' ndiyo chiyero chatinofanira kushandisa. Asi Chechi pachayo haidzidzisi izvozvo. 
• Anotaura kuti Madzibaba eChechi ekutanga aidzidzisa nezvehumambo hwenyama hwaiuya uye nenguva yemaropafadzo emweya vaive mukukanganisa (millenarianism). Ruzivo rwakanyanya uye rwenguva pfupi yapfuura, zvisinei, runosimbisa kariro dzaMadzibaba eChechi.
• VaAkin vanorangarira rinopfuura zana ramakore redzidziso yapapa inosimbisa “nguva iri kuuya yorugare” noutsvene se“fungidziro” zvayo. Zvisinei, Katekisimu inotsinhira kuti Magisterium akajairika eChechi haadi ex cathedra mutauro.
• Anopa mienzaniso miviri yaanoti isu takabvisa vanapapa kunze kwechirevo. Mukupesana, mienzaniso yake miviri inosimbisa dzidziso yapapa neMagwaro. 
• VaAkin vanosimbirira kuti Fatima chinhu chekare. Benedict XVI haabvumirani nazvo. 
• Anokurudzira kuti Countdown iri kutyora mutemo pane zvakanyorwa naLuisa Piccarreta uye kuti Fr. Michel Rodrigue, mumwe wevaoni watiri kuona pane ino saiti, anonyeperwa kana murevi wenhema. Tine chimwe chinhu chekutaura nezvekurwiswa kunonyadzisa uku kwehunhu hwaAbbot.

 

Pamusoro pekuvimbika kwemaitiro edu ekunzwisisa

VaAkin vanoti:

Hapana pandaireva kuti muoni kushaya mvumo kuChurch zvinoreva kuti muoni haavimbike. Panzvimbo pezvo, ndakanyora kuti: “Kudzika kwasarudza kusashandisa mvumo yeChechi semwero wevaoni sevanovimbika. Kuongorora kwayo pachayo kwakavimbika zvakadini?”

Chirevo ichi chinoita sechinopesana. Kana muoni achigona kuvimbika pasina mvumo yeChechi, sezvinoreva VaAkin, sei zvino ari kutaura kuti “mvumo yeChechi” inofanira kuva iyo chete chiyero chatinoongorora nayo kuvimbika kwekuzarurwa kwepachivande? Anoratidzika kunge ari kuyedza kukanda mumvuri kune chero muoni asina chiziviso chepamutemo che "mvumo" - kunyangwe kubvumidzwa kwakadaro kuri kushoma apo vaoni vachiri kugamuchira nekupa zvakazarurwa. Zviripachena, chimiro chechechi, saka, chingori chimwe chezvizhinji zvinotariswa kana zvasvika kune vanocherekedza vaoni uye kwete kana mwero unodiwa neChechi pachayo. Uyezve, rudzi rwemvumo yaVaAkin iri mupfungwa - yakabudiswa neVatican "constat de supernaturalitate" - haambopiwi chero muoni. Kunyange zvakazarurwa zvaSt. Faustina hazvina kugamuchira chirevo chakadaro. Zviripachena, saka, kuganhurira kufunga kwedu kuzarurirwa kwepachivande kune avo chete vane mvumo yerudzi irworwo hazvidiwi zvachose uye zvinosekesa kutaura sezviri madikanwa.

Kubva pakabviswa Canon 1399 uye 2318 yeyaimbova Code of Canon Law naPope Paul VI muAAS 58 (1966), zvinyorwa pamusoro pezviratidziro zvitsva, zvakazarurwa, zviporofita, zvishamiso, nezvimwe zvakabvumidzwa kugovaniswa nekuverengwa nevakatendeka. pasina mvumo yeChechi, kunze kwekunge vasina chinhu chinopikisana nerutendo nehunhu. Izvi zvinoreva kuti kunyange a Imprimatur hazvidiwi. Naizvozvo, meseji yese paKuverengera kuHumambo (CTTK) inofanira kutanga yapasa bvunzo ye litmus ye orthodoxy. Kukarakadza munzira ipi neipi, ipapoka, kuti chizaruro chapachivande chinofanira “kutenderwa” kuti chiverengwe kana kuti kunzwisiswa, kana kuti kunyange kudavirwa, kunotsausa. 

Mumwe anowana fungidziro yekuti VaAkin vanotenda kuti tinoshambadza chirevo chese kune zvakazarurwa zvakavanzika zvinodarika madhesiki edu. Zvirokwazvo, tinogashira tsamba kubva kuvanhu vanoti vakagamuchira zvakazarurwa zvakavanzika. Zvisinei, zvinenge zvose izvi zvinoita kwete kuonekwa paCTTK. Chikonzero ndechekuti kazhinji hapana nzira yekusimbisa kuvimbika kwezvirevo zvakadaro. St. John weMuchinjikwa akanyevera pamusoro pekugona kuzvinyengedza:

Ndinoshamiswa nezviri kuitika mumazuva ano—kureva, apo mumwe mweya une ruzivo ruduku zvikuru rwekufungisisa, kana uchiziva dzimwe nzvimbo dzerudzi urwu mune imwe mamiriro ekurangarira, pakarepo unodzibhabhatidza dzose sedzinobva kuna Mwari, uye anofungidzira kuti ndizvo zvazviri, achiti: “Mwari akati kwandiri…”; “Mwari vakandipindura…”; Asi kana zvisakadaro, asi sezvatareva, vazhinji ndivo vari kutaura zvinhu izvi mumwoyo mavo. Uye, pamusoro peizvi, chishuwo icho vanhu vanacho chekutsvaga, uye kufara kunouya kumweya yavo kubva kwavari, kunovatungamira kuti vazvipindure ivo vobva vafunga kuti ndiMwari Ari kuvapindura uye achitaura kwavari. —St. Johane weMuchinjikwa, Iyo Aszana reGomo reKameri, Bhuku 2, Chitsauko 29, n. 4-5

Ndiko kusaka kuperekedza zviitiko zvemweya zvakadai sekunyadziswa, zvishamiso, kushorwa kwemifananidzo nezvidhori, kutendeuka, nezvimwewo zvichionekwa neChechi sehumwe humbowo hwekutaura kune mavambo emweya ezvakazarurwa zvataurwa. Ungano Inoera yeDzidziso yeKutenda inoramba pfungwa yekuti zvibereko hazvina basa. Inonyatso reva kukosha kana zvakazarurwa zvakadaro…

Chizaruro chakavanzika chinogona kuve chakachengeteka vakatenda mushure mekunyatsonzwisisa pasina Kubvumirwa nechechi. Vaoni veFatima, somuenzaniso, vakarangarirwa kuva “vakavimbika” zvikuru pasina mvumo yeChechi (iyo yakatora makore 13 pashure pe“chishamiso chezuva” chakakurumbira). St. Pio, St. Faustina, Muranda waMwari Luisa Piccarreta, zvichingodaro vese mienzaniso yevasinganzwisisike vakapa zvakazarurwa zvakatendwa zvichibva paumbowo huripo uye hukuru. Kutenda uye kufunga hazvipikiswe; ie. kufunga, kunovhenekerwa nokutenda, kunogona kutisvitsa pakunzwisisa kwakafanira. Kunyange zvazvo VaAkin vachiti, "kushayikwa kwekuverenga nekunyatsoongorora kwakajairika paKuverenga", anoita seasina kunyatsoverenga mhinduro yangu yekutanga, iyo yaisanganisira mazwi aBenedict XIV pamusoro pekuti "kubvumirwa kweChechi" ndiyo chete yakavimbika. chiyero chekuongorora chiporofita:

Ndivo here vakazarurirwa, uye avo vanoziva kuti zvinobva kuna Mwari, unosungirwa kupa chibvumirano chakasimba nazvo? Mhinduro iri mukusimbisa… Uyo anotaurirwa chizaruro ichi kana kuziviswa, anofanira kutenda nokuteerera murayiro kana shoko raMwari, kana achinge audzwa noumbowo hwakakwana… Nokuti Mwari anotaura naye kunyange nomutowo uyu. womumwe, naizvozvo unoda kuti atende; saka zviri, kuti anosungirwa kutenda Mwari, Anoda kuti adaro. -Heroic Hunhu, Vol III, p.390, p. 394

Pakupedzisira, inoda kudzokororwa: nekudhinda mameseji evamwe vaoni paCTTK, hatisi kuita chiziviso chechokwadi chavo asi kuvakurudzira chaizvo kuti vaonekwe neChechi yese. Zvekare, dai VaAkin vakanyatsoverenga nekuongorora zviri pawebhusaiti yedu, vangadai vakawana pane yedu peji rekutanga Disclaimer, inoti:

Isu hatisi vatongi vekupedzisira vezvakazarurwa zvechokwadi—Chechi ndiyo—uye tinozogara tichizviisa pasi pechipi zvacho chaanosarudza. Ndizvo ne Chechi, saka, kuti isu "tinoedza" chiporofita: "Kutungamirirwa neMagisterium yeKereke, iyo sensus fidelium anoziva kuziva nekutambira mune zvakazarurwa izvi chero zvinodaidza Kristu kana vasande vake kuChechi. ” (Katekisimo yeChechi yeKaturike, n. 67)

Izvo zvinoti "kutungamirwa" kwete "kusarudzwa" neMagisterium. 

 

PaMadzibaba eChechi

VaAkin vanoti:

Zvinoshamisa kuti [Mark Mallett] anotaura kunzwisisa kweMadzibaba kwemireniyamu, nekuti vanaBaba vanopokana pane izvi. Mukutsigira kunzwisisa kwaCountdown, VaMallett vanotaura kwekutanga masosi senge Tsamba yaBhanabhasi, Papias, Justin Martyr, Irenaeus, uye Tertullian pamireniyumu. Asi anotadza kutaura kuti patristics nyanzvi dzinoziva chimwe nechimwe yezvitubu izvi sekutsigira chiuru chemakore - maonero ekuti kuchave nekumuka kwenyama kwevakarurama, mushure mezvo vachatonga naKristu pasi pano kwenguva yakareba mutongo wekupedzisira usati wasvika (zvese Chechi neKuverengera rega millenarianism).

Pano, VaAkin vanoratidzikawo sevanosarudza, vachikundikana kutaura basa rakatanhamara renyanzvi yokudisa nyika Rev. Joseph Iannuzzi Ph.B., STB, M. Div., STL, STD, uyo akapa zvakawanda zveupenyu hwake nezvinyorwa kuna kukudziridza dzidziso yezveuMwari yemireniyamu neNguva yeRugare iri kuuya; Dr. Françoise Breynaert, Kuuya Kunobwinya kwaKristu neMireniyamu (2019); uye Purofesa Jacques Cabaud, Panguva Yokupedzisira (2019).

Mukuongorora kumutsidzirwa kwekukunda kwechiKristu, vanyori vazhinji vakafungidzira maitiro echikoro, uye vakakanda mimvuri yekukahadzika pazvinyorwa zvekutanga zveVaApostora Madzibaba. Vazhinji vasvika padyo nekuvati ndevanyengeri, nekukanganisa vachienzanisa dzidziso dzavo "dzisina kuvandudzwa" pamireniyamu neidzo dzemasekete anotsauka. —Fr. Joseph Iannuzzi, Kukunda kweHumambo hwaMwari muMireniyamu neKupera Nguva: Kutenda Kwakakodzera kubva kuChokwadi muMagwaro uye Dzidziso dzeChechi, St. John Muvhangeri Press, 1999, peji. 11

Ndanyorawo bhuku panyaya iyi inonzi Kutarisana kwekupedzisira, iyo yakagamuchira Nihil Obstat. Muzvinafundo Daniel O'Connor (uyo ari chipangamazano kuCTTK) akapawo kudzivirira kwakazara kweMadzibaba eChechi neNguva yeRunyararo mumabasa akawanda akadai se. Korona yehutsvene uye bhuku rake razvino, Kuda Kwenyu Ngakuitwe. Pamusoro pazvo, muturikiri wemashoko ewebhusaiti ino, Peter Bannister, MTh, MPhil, anonyatsoziva zvinyorwa zvechitendero chemireniyamu uye maungira azvo muchiporofita chemazuva ano. Naizvozvo, tinopokana nemwoyo wese nemafungiro aVaAkin ekuti "kushaikwa kwekunyatsoverenga uye kuongorora kwakajairika paKuverengera" uye kuti takundikana kufunga kuti vamwe vanaBaba veChechi havana kubvumirana pakati pavo (ini ndanyatsotaura izvi. pano, chinyorwa chandingadai ndakagovera kuna VaAkin nyore nyore kudai akanga abvunza).

Munhu anofanirwa kumbomira ofunga kuti mamwe Madzibaba eChechi,^[1]“… njere huru dzemazana emakore ekutanga eChechi, ine zvinyorwa, mharidzo nehupenyu hutsvene zvakapesvedzera zvinoshamisa tsananguro, kudzivirira nekuparadzirwa kweKutenda”, Catholic Encyclopedia, Sunday Visitor Publications, 1991, p. 399. St. Vincent weLerins akanyora: “… kana mumwe mubvunzo mutsva ukamuka usina kupihwa sarudzo yakadaro, ivo vanofanirwa kubva vatora pfungwa dzeMadzibaba vatsvene, dzeavo, avo, mumwe nemumwe munguva yake nenzvimbo, vachigara mukubatana kwe. kuyanana uye nokutenda vakagamuchirwa savatenzi vakatenderwa; uye chipi kana chipi icho ikoku kungawanwa kuva kwakachengeta, nomurangariro mumwe uye nebvumirano imwe, ikoku kunofanira kurangarirwa kuva dzidziso yechokwadi neyeKaturike yeChechi, pasina kupokana kupi nokupi kana kuti kupokana.” -Zvakajairika ra434 AD, "YeAntiquity neUniversal yeCatholic Faith Against the Profane Novelties of All Heresies", Ch. 29, n. 77 vakadai saPapias, vakagamuchira nzwisiso yavo yemireniyumu chaizvoizvo kubva mudzidziso yokutanga yaSt. Kuramba izvi senhema, sezvinoratidzwa naVaAkin, zvinokatyamadza pachazvo, kunyangwe paine kuita mhedziso dzemillenarianism muzvinyorwa zveMadzibaba eChechi. 

Chokwadi, kushandiswa zvisirizvo kwedzidziso dzaPapias kune dzimwe dzidziso dzechiJudha-dzechiKristu dzekare dzakabuda chaizvo kubva pamafungiro asiri iwo. Vamwe vafundisi vakasaziva vakatora nzira yekufungidzira yaEusebius…. Shure kwaizvozvo, mafungiro aya akabatanidza zvese nezvose zvinoenderana nemireniyamu ne Chiliasm, zvichikonzera kukanganisa kusingagadziriswe mumunda weeschatology iyo yaizogara kwechinguva, senge ubiquitous striction, yakasungirirwa kune izwi rakakosha. mireniyamu. —Fr. Joseph Iannuzzi, Kukunda kweHumambo hwaMwari muMireniyamu neKupera Nguva: Kutenda Kwakakodzera kubva kuChokwadi muMagwaro uye Dzidziso dzeChechi, St. John Muvhangeri Press, 1999, peji. 20

Nehurombo, VaAkin havaite mutsauko wakajeka weizvo chaizvo zvinoumba dzidziso yenhema yemireniyani. The Catechism yeChechi yeKaturike rinoti:

Ini nemaune ndakasiya mumashoko emuzasi ari pamusoro nekuti akakosha mukutibatsira kuti tinzwisise zvinorehwa ne "millenarianism", uye rwechipiri, "messianism yenyika" muCatechism.

Pazasi 577 inoreva basa raDenzinger-Schonnmetzer (Enchiridion Symbolorum, tsanangudzo uye kududzirwa uye rebus fidei et morum). Basa raDenzinger rinoteedzera kuvandudzwa kwedzidziso uye Dzidziso muChechi yeKaturike kubva panguva dzayo dzekare, uye zviri pachena kuti zvinoonekwa senzvimbo yakatendeka yekatekisimu yekutora. Izwi remuzasi ku "millenarianism" rinotitungamira kubasa raDenzinger, rinoti:

… Hurongwa hweMillenarianism hwakadzikira, hunodzidzisa, semuenzaniso, kuti Kristu Ishe pamberi pekutongwa kwekupedzisira, kungave kana kusati kwambotangira kumutswa kwevakawanda vakarurama, achauya zvinoonekwa kuzotonga pasi rino. Mhinduro ndeiyi: Iyo system yeakadzikiswa Millenarianism haigone kudzidziswa zvakachengeteka. —DS 2269/3839, Chirevo cheHofisi Tsvene, Chikunguru 21, 1944

Chero nguva iyo Madzibaba eKereke pavanotaura nezve zororo reSabata kana nguva yerunyararo, havafungi nezvekudzoka kwaJesu munyama, kana kuguma kwenhoroondo yevanhu, asi vanowedzera simba reMweya Mutsvene rinoshandura mumasakaramende anoita kuti Chechi ikwane. kuti Kristu amugadzirire kwaari semwenga asina mwero pakudzoka kwake kwekupedzisira. —Zvak. JL Iannuzzi, Kubwinya kweChisiko, p. 79

Zvinhu zviviri zvekucherekedza pano: Chechi hairambi mukana weimwe mhando ye“kumuka kwevakarurama”, inova inotangira murondedzero yeKumuka kuvakafa kwaKristu.^[2]ona Kumuka Kumutswa uye Kumutswa kweChechi

Kusimbiswa kwakakosha ndekwe nhanho yepakati umo vatsvene vakamutswa vachiri pasi pano uye vasati vapinda muchikamu chavo chekupedzisira, nekuti ichi ndicho chimwe chezvinhu zvakavanzika zvemazuva ekupedzisira izvo zvisati zvaziviswa. —Cardinal Jean Daniélou (1905-1974), Nhoroondo yeKutanga kwechiKristu Dzidziso Pamberi peDare reNicea, 1964, p. 377

Chechipiri, Millenarianism, anonyora Leo J. Trese mukati Kutenda Kunotsanangurwa, ndezve kuna avo vanotora Zvakazarurwa 20: 6 chaiko.

St John, achitsanangura chiratidzo chechiporofita (Zva 20: 1-6), anoti dhiabhori achasungwa nekuiswa mutirongo kwemakore chiuru, panguva iyo vakafa vachararama nekutonga naKristu; pakupera kwezviuru zvemakore, dhiabhorosi achaburitswa uye pakupedzisira achakundwa zvachose, uyezve kuchauya kumuka kwechipiri… Avo vanotora ndima iyi sezvairi uye vachitenda kuti Jesu achauya kuzotonga pasi pano kwemakore ane chiuru nyika isati yaguma vanodaidzwa kunzi mamirioni. .P. 153-154, Sinag-Tala Vaparidzi, Inc. (pamwe ne Nihil Obstat uye Imprimatur)

Cardinal Jean Daniélou anopfupikisa:

Millenarianism, iko kutenda kwekuti kuchave ne wepanyika kutonga kwaMesiya nguva yekupera isati yasvika, dzidziso yechiJuda-Christian yakamuka uye inoenderera ichimutsa kupokana kwakawanda kupfuura chero chipi zvacho. -Nhoroondo yeKutanga kwechiKristu Dzidziso, p. 377 (sezvakataurwa mu Kubwinya kweChisiko, p. 198-199, Mufundisi Joseph Iannuzzi)

Anowedzera kuti, “Chikonzero cheizvi, zvisinei, zvichida kukundikana kusiyanisa zvinhu zvakasiyana-siyana zvedzidziso."^[3]“Munhu haafanire kuenzanisa millenarianism yemweya ne“zvikomborero zvomudzimu” zvenguva yorugare zviri muzvinyorwa zvaMadzibaba naVanachiremba vapakuvamba. Tsika dzakatsigira dudziro yemweya yenguva yerunyararo. Ukuwo, millenarianism yemweya inosimudzira pfungwa yokuti Kristu achadzokera pasi pano Rutongeso Rwose rusati rwavapo uye achatonga zvinooneka kwemakore 1,000 XNUMX chaiwoiwo. Zvisinei, aisazotora rutivi mumabiko enyama asina mwero. Saka zita remweya. " —Iannuzzi, Mufundisi Joseph. Kubwinya kweChisiko: Kukunda kweKuda kwaMwari Pasi uye Era yerunyararo mune zvakanyorwa zveMadzibaba Chechi, Vanachiremba uye Vangu, Kindle Edition.

Chinyorwa chepasi cheCatechism 578, sezvataurwa pamusoro apa, chinotiunza kugwaro Divini Redemptoris, Pope Pius XI's Encyclical against Atheistic Communism. Nepo mamillenarians vakabatirira kune imwe chimiro cheutopian quasi-wemweya humambo, Masiasi echihedheni batirira hushe hwehumambo hwematongerwo enyika.

Chikominisi chanhasi, zvakanyanya zvine simba kupfuura kufamba kwakafanana munguva yakapfuura, chinovanza mukati mayo manyepo enhema emesiya. —Papa PIUS XI, Divini Redemptoris, n. 8, www.haav.va

(Sechinyorwa chepadivi, ndingakurudzira Mr. Akin kuti vafunge kuti "Kugadzirisazve Kwakakura ” - uye kwete dzidziso yeNguva yeRugare - inoumba iyo zvechokwadi tyisidziro kune vakatendeka veKatorike, chokwadi, vanhu vese. Chinenge chiKomonisiti “ine ngowani yegirini.”)

Mumhedziso, Chechi inoshora here kariro yeNguva yoRugare mukati meinonzi “makore ane chiuru” aZvakazarurwa 20? Padre Martino Penasa paakataura naMsgr. S. Garofalo (Mupi wezano kuUngano yeChikonzero cheVatendi) pahwaro hwemagwaro eNguva yeRunyararo yenhoroondo uye yepasirese, kusiyana nemirenarianism, Msgr. akakurudzira kuti nyaya yacho imiswe zvakananga kuUngano yeDzidziso yeKutenda. Fr. Saka Martino akabvunza mubvunzo uyu: “Imminente una nuova era di vita cristiana?"(" Nguva itsva yehupenyu hwechiKristu yave pedyo here? "). Mutungamiriri panguva iyoyo, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger vakapindura, "La kutakaione è ancora aperta alla libera negotiione, giacchè la Santa Sede non si è ancoraataataata mu modo ufafanuzi":

Mubvunzo uchiri wakazaruka kurukurirano yemahara, seizvo Holy See isina kuita chero chirevo mune izvi. -Il Segno del Soprannauturale, Udine, Italia, n. 30, map. 10, Ott. 1990; Fr. Martino Penasa akapa mubvunzo uyu we "mamirioni kutonga" kuna Cardinal Ratzinger

 

PaMagisterium

VaAkin vanoti:

Panyaya yeMagisterium, hapana nzira iri nyore yekutaura izvi, asi vanyori veCountdown havaratidzike sevane kunzwisisa kwakajeka kwezvinoumba chiito chehutongi kana dzidziso yeChechi.

Nehurombo, VaAkin havana kungwarira kuverenga misiyano yandakaita, uye ini handinyoreri kune dudziro yavo yezvinonzi dzidziso ye "magisterial". Pandakanokora mashoko mabhishopi, makadhinari, uye vanapapa, ndakaita kudaro sedzidziso dzamagisteri. Pandakataura Fr. Charles naSt. Louis de Montfort, ndakanga ndakangwarira kutaura kuti ivo "dzidziso dzechechi" - kureva. kubva kuvafundisi. Zvisinei, VaAkin vanoti zvinokatyamadza vanoramba zana rinopfuura zana redzidziso dzapapa dziri mumagwaro epamusoro-soro amagisitiriti anotaura zvakajeka nezveNguva yoRugare, nokudzidana kuti “fungidziro” zvayo. Tinopokana kuti zvichibva muMagwaro, uchapupu hweMadzibaba eChechi, magwaro akawanda emagisitiriti, uye zvisimbiso mune zvakazarurwa zvechiporofita, mabhishopi, makadhinari nemapapa vanosimbisa tarisiro iyi “vari kushandisa Magisteriumwo zvawo”. The Catechism yeChechi yeKaturike rinoti:

Rubatsiro rwoumwari runopiwawo kuvatsivi vavaapostora, kudzidzisa mukuyanana nomutsivi waPetro, uye, nenzira yakati, kuna bhishopi weRoma, mufundisi weChechi yose, apo, pasina kusvika patsanangudzo isingakanganisi uye pasina. vachidudza no“mutoo wakajeka,” ivo vanokarakadza mukushandiswa kweMagisteriumwo zvayo dzidziso inotungamirira kukunzwisiswa kuri nani kwaZvakazarurwa munhau dzokutenda netsika. —N. 892

Mufundisi Iannuzzi vanopokana vachiti:

VanaBaba veChechi vakawanda vapakuvamba, Vanachiremba navazivikanwi vakadeya kutaura nguva dzose nguva yorugare noutsvene hukuru hwechiKristu, nokudaro vachipa ufakazi hwokutsigira chimiro chokuti iyi dzidziso rutivi uye rutivi rwegamuchidzanwa reChechi.. -Kubwinya kweChisiko: Kukunda kweKuda kwaMwari Pasi uye Era yerunyararo mune zvakanyorwa zveMadzibaba Chechi, Vanachiremba uye Vangu,loc. 4747, Kindle Edition

Tinokatyamadzwa pachena nokupenya uko VaAkins vanobata nako kubvumirana kwapapa vachisimbisa Tsika dzeChechi panguva inouya youtsvene hwokukunda. Chokwadi ndechekuti ex-cathedra mutauro hauna kushandiswa mukati meEncyclicals aya, nezvimwewo kutaura nezveNguva yeRunyararo hazvireve kuti Era haina kudzidziswa zvine hungwaru.  

Nezve mamwe magisterial sources, Dzidziso dzeChechi yeKaturike, rakabudiswa nesangano rezvidzidzo zvouMwari muna 1952, rakagumisa kuti hazvipesani nedzidziso yeKaturike kudavira kana kuti kutaura…

… Tariro mune kumwe kukunda kukuru kwaKristu pano panyika kuguma kwekupedzisira kwezvinhu zvose kusati kwasvika. Chiitiko chakadai hachina kubviswa, hachisi chinhu chinogoneka, hazvisi zvese zvine chokwadi chekuti hakuzove nenguva yakareba yechiKristu chinokunda mugumo usati wasvika.

Vachibvisa millenarianism, vanogumisa nenzira kwayo:

Kana pamberi pegumo iro rekupedzisira paine nguva, yakawanda kana shoma, yehutsvene hwekukunda, mhedzisiro yakadaro ichaunzwa kwete nekuvonekwa kwemunhu waKristu muhukuru asi nekushanda kwemasimba iwayo ehutsvene ayo ikozvino pabasa, Mweya Mutsvene uye maSakaramende eChechi. -Kudzidzisa kweChechi yeKaturike: Chidimbu cheChechi yeKaturike (London: Burns Oates & Washbourne, 1952), peji. 1140

 

Kunze kwechirevo?

VaAkin vanoti:

Kuverengera kunotora zvirevo kunze kwechirevo kuti zvienderane nemamiriro enguva yemberi. Apo Benedict XV akafungidzira muna 1914 nezvehondo dzaimuka muzuva rake, akanga achitaura nezveHondo Yenyika I, iyo yakanga yatanga mwedzi mishoma yapfuura. Uye apo Pius XII akafungidzira muna 1944 nezvenguva itsva inokarirwa. akanga achitaura nezvokupera kweHondo Yenyika II, iyo yakaguma muEurope mwedzi mishomanana gare gare.

Sezvineiwo, ndiVaAkin avo vakatora Pius XII kunze kwechirevo yezvaimbotaurwa napapa, kunyanya iye akafanotangira ane zita chairo raakataura. Makumi anoverengeka amakore Hondo Yenyika II isati yasvika, Pope St. Pius X akanga achitozivisa muEncyclical (ari mabhii apapa ayo “anojekesa dzidziso iripo sorutivi rwechiremerawo zvacho chokudzidzisa chaBaba Vatsvene”^[4]library.athenaeum.edu ) pa“kudzorerwa kwezvinhu zvose muna Kristu” kuri kuuya.^[5]E Supremi, October 4th, 1903 Kuti Pope Pius XII akabva atarisira “kuvandudzwa, kurongeka patsva kwenyika” zvine nharo kuenderera mberi kwepfungwa yaSt. Pius X - uye nekukurumidza, pasina kupokana.

Vamwe vanozowanikwa avo vanoyera zvinhu zveUmwari nemaitiro evanhu vachatsvaga kutsvaga zvakavanzika zvinangwa zveKwedu, vachizvikanganisa kusvika pasirese uye kune mapato ezvematongerwo enyika. —PAPA ST. PIUS X, E Supremi, kwete. 4

Kana ari Benedict XV, zvamazvirokwazvo akanga achifungidzira nenzira yakajeka, pamwe chete napapa vakapfuura, kuti nyongano yenyika yose nokumukira kwakanga kuri chiratidzo chokuti uporofita hweEvhangeri hwakanga huri. kutanga kufutunura:

Zvamazvirokwazvo, mazuva iwayo aizoita seakasvika patiri uyo Kristu Ishe wedu akafanotaura nezvawo: “Muchanzwa zvehondo nerunyerekupe rwehondo, nekuti rudzi ruchamukira rudzi, neushe huchamukira ushe" (Mat. 24: 6-7). —PAPA BENEDICT XV, Ad Beatissimi Apostolorum, November 1, 1914

Izwi rakakosha pano ndere "kutanga." Chokwadi, Ishe wedu akataura nezvehondo idzi se “marwadzo ekusununguka”, kwete kuzvara chaiko. 

Zvose izvi kutanga kwemarwadzo emimba. (Mateo 24: 8)

 

Fatima akazadzisa?

VaAkin vanoramba vachiomerera kuti Fatima ikozvino chidzidzo chekare chekare, achitaura nezvetsanangudzo yebhaibheri yaCardinal Joseph Ratzinger. Zvisineyi, kunyangwe tsinhiro iyi, uye zvirevo zveramangwana zvemufundisi mumwechete paakava papa, zvinonyatsoratidza kuti “basa” raFatima kwete yakakwana uye ichine chirevo chenguva yemberi. Kubva pane tsananguro:

Ngirozi ine munondo unopfuta kuruboshwe rwaAmai vaMwari inorangarira mifananidzo yakafanana muBhuku raZvakazarurwa. Izvi zvinomiririra kutyisidzira kwekutongwa kuri kuitika munyika. Nhasi tarisiro yekuti nyika ingaitwa madota negungwa remoto haicharatidziki sekufungidzira kwakachena: munhu pachake, nezvigadzirwa zvake, akagadzira munondo unopfuta… ramangwana. -v Vatican.va

Mune mamwe mazwi, mhinduro yedu kumharidzo yeFatima icharamba ichitaura ramangwana. Nekudaro, Pope Benedict anozosimbisa kuti Fatima haisi meseji yekare:

...tingakanganisa kufunga kuti basa rechiporofita reFatima rakwana. —Homily, May 13, 2010, Fatima, Portugal; Catholic News Agency

Handina chokwadi kuti chii chisina kujeka kuna VaAkin panguva ino. Semuenzaniso, "nguva yerunyararo" yakavimbiswa naMukadzi Wedu weFatima haisati yasvika.^[6]cf. Iyo Runyararo Nguva Yakatove Yakaitika Here? Zvikasadaro, sei Pope Benedict akanamatira Rukundo urwu?

Dai makore manomwe anotiparadzanisa kubva kuzana remakore rezviratidziro akurumidze kuzadzikiswa kwechiporofita chekukunda kweMwoyo Wakachena waMay, kune mbiri yeUtatu Hutsvene Hutsvene. —POPE BENEDICT XVI, Chivabvu 13, 2010, Catholic News Agency

 Uprofita hupi?

Mukupedzisira, wangu Wakachena Moyo uchakunda. Baba Vatsvene vachatsaura Russia kwandiri, uye iye achashandurwa, uye nguva yerunyararo ichapihwa pasi rose. —Mudzimai wedu kumuoni Sr. Lucia; tsamba kuna Baba Vatsvene, May 12, 1982; Mharidzo yeFatima, v Vatican.va

Ehe, chishamiso chakavimbiswa paFatima, chishamiso chikuru pane zvese nhoroondo dzepiri, chechipiri chekumuka kuvakafa. Uye chishamiso icho chichava nguva yerunyararo, isina kumbobvira yapiwa pamberi penyika kunyangwe. —Cardinal Mario Luigi Ciappi, mufundisi wechitendero chepapa waPius XII, John XXIII, Paul VI, John Paul I, naJohn Paul II, Gumiguru 9, 1994, Katekisheni yemhuri yekwaApostora, p. 35

 

Vaoni

Ndakatopindura zvakawanda zvekutaura kwaVaAkin kuti hatina "kufunga kwakadzama" kana zvasvika kune vaoni, muchikamu chekutanga pamusoro. Zvinosuruvarisa, kunoratidzika kunge kusina kushayikwa kwekutonga kwechimbichimbi kuna VaAkin - murume asiri chikamu chekushanda kwezuva nezuva, nhaurirano, uye kunzwisisa kunoitika pasi pemapapiro edzidziso nenhungamiro yeChechi. 

Pakunonoka Fr. Stefano Gobbi, isu hatina kubatanidza zvinoita sechiporofita "kupotsa" maererano nehuporofita hwake hwakanangana negore ra2000 nezvikonzero izvo mameseji pachawo anotsanangura - uye zvakafanana nezvaiitwa naBenedict XVI mutsanangudzo yake pamusoro paFatima:

…magadzirirwo eKururama kwaMwari, anogona kushandurwa nesimba reRudo Rwake rune tsitsi. Kunyange pandinokutaurira nezvokurangwa, rangarira kuti zvinhu zvose zvinogona kushandurwa pakarepo nesimba romunyengetero wako uye nokutendeuka kwako kunotsiva. Saka usati “Zvamakatitaurira hazvina kuitika!”, asi tenda Baba Vekudenga vaneni nekuti, kuburikidza nemhinduro yemunamato nekuzvitsaurira, kuburikidza nekutambudzika kwako, kuburikidza nekutambudzika kukuru kwevazhinji vevana vangu varombo, Akabvisa zvakare nguva yeRuramisiro, kuti abvumire nguva yeTsitsi huru kuti itumbuke. —January 21, 1984; Kune Vapirisiti, Vana Vedu Vanodikanwa

Ini ndinobvuma kuti isu tinofanira kuwedzera izvi kune yake biography kune vanopokana - asi haina kusiiwa nemaune. 

On Muranda waMwari Luisa Piccarreta, VaAkin vanotaura kuti Countdown “haitauri nezvayo chirevo chabhishopi wake, iyo ichiri kushanda uye inoti: "

Ndinofanira kutaura nezvekuwedzera uye kusatariswa mafashama ezvinyorwa, dudziro uye zvinyorwa kuburikidza nekudhinda uye internet. Chero zvazvingava, “tichiona kupfava kwechikamu chazvino chenyaya, kuburitswa kwese kwezvinyorwa zvachose kurambidzwa panguva ino. Ani naani anoita zvinopesana neizvi haateereri uye anokuvadza zvikuru chikonzero cheMuranda waMwari (kusimbisa mukutanga). [aimbova Bhishopi mukuru weTrani, Giovanni Battista Pichierri]

Kuverengera kunoratidzika kunge kutyora mutemo uyu nekuburitsa zvinyorwa kubva muzvinyorwa zvake (semuenzaniso, pano).

Mukupesana, CTTK haina "kuburitsa" zvinyorwa zveMuranda waMwari Luisa Piccarreta. Chirevo cheDiocese chakataurwa naVaAkin chinongorambidza kuburitswa kwevhoriyamu yavo, kwete kutorwa kwezvikamu. Mukati memutemo mumwechetewo wakataurwa naVaAkin, bhishopi mushakabvu akaunyora akasimbirira kuti zvakanyorwa naLuisa zviverengwe nekugovaniswa (ona. Pane Zvakanyorwa naLuisa Piccarreta) Chirevo chose uye kufunga kwakakodzera zvinogona kuwanikwa muzvinyorwa zvee-Book remahara, Korona yehutsvene naProf. Daniel O'Connor.

Pamunhu anonzi muoni Fr. Michel Rodrigue, VaAkin vanoti:

Mhosva yakaipisisa yekushaikwa kwe Countdown yekufunga kwakadzama kusimudzira kwayo Fr. Michel Rodrigue… murume uyu haavimbike. 

Pano, VaAkin vakawira kwete mukutonga kwechimbichimbi chete asi kunyomba uye unyengeri. Nekuti anoti muzvinyorwa zvake zviviri:

Webhusaiti ye[Countdown] hairatidze humbowo hwekuti vanyori vakaita ongororo yakadzama yevaoni vavanokurudzira kana, kana vaine, kuti vakashandisa kufunga kwakadzama kunyaya dzavo uye nekuyera humbowo.

Tinoda kubvunza VaAkin kana vakaita ongororo yakadzama yaFr. Michel izvo zvinoenderana nemhedziso dzake? Ko Mr. Akin vakabatana naFr. Michel kumubvunzurudza uye kumubvunza nezve huchapupu hwake? Ko Jimmy Akin akaedza kubata chero munhu muFr. Denderedzwa raMichel rekuonesa nyaya dzake nehupenyu? Uye Mr. Akin vanoziva sei kuti ini kana ani zvake pachikwata chedu anonzwa sei nezvaFr. Zvikumbiro zvaMichel uye kusimudzira, kana chero mumwe muoni paCountdown, isu tichiramba tichiziva uye nekuzviyedza? Sei VaAkin vachifungidzira kuti hapana kuenderera mberi kushoropodza, mibvunzo, kana kusagutsikana maererano naFr. Michel kana chero mumwe muoni? Sekuziva kwangu, VaAkin vanga vasina kuonana naFr. Michel kana timu yedu kuona uye kuchera zvakadzika. Pane kudaro, anogumisa kuti "Fr. Rodrigue haakwanisi kuparadzanisa fungidziro kubva kune chokwadi kana kuti ari kutaura manyepo anozvikudza. " Ino inguva inosiririsa yekumisa kupomerwa uku pachena, pasina hwaro hwakakwana, kune chero munhu - ndoda mumwe wevakuru veCatholic Mhinduro.

NdiFr. Michel a real mystic? Ini pachangu, mubvunzo iwoyo unoramba usina kwawakarerekera pandinoramba ndichiyedza zviporofita zvake nezvaanoreva. Asi nezve hupirisita hwake nedzidziso dzechokwadi dzekutenda, hapana mubvunzo kuti Fr. Michel anga ari muranda akatendeka. Tsamba dzatakagamuchira dzinopupurira kushandurwa kunoshamisa kuburikidza naFr. Kudzokera kwaMichel kwakakwana kuti ini ndirambe ndichiona uye kuyera zvinhu zvechiporofita - izvo Mr. Akin kana chero ani zvake akasununguka kuisa parutivi. Zvisinei, havana kusununguka kuisa parutivi dzidziso dzeKatekisimu:

Kuremekedza mukurumbira vanhu vanorambidza mafungiro ose nemashoko angangokonzera kuvakuvadza kusina kururama. Anova nemhosva:

- of kukurumidza kutonga uyo, kunyangwe zvinyoronyoro, anotora sechokwadi, pasina hwaro hwakakwana, mhosva yetsika yemuvakidzani;

- of kukanganisa uyo, pasina chikonzero chakaringana chikonzero, anofumura zvikanganiso zveumwe nekutadza kune vanhu vaisazviziva;

- of calumny uyo, nekutaura kunopesana nechokwadi, anokuvadza mukurumbira wevamwe uye anopa mukana wekutongwa kwenhema pamusoro pavo. —N. 2477

 

 

Resources

Pakucherekedza chiporofita neKereke: Chiporofita mumaonero

PaMadzibaba eChechi Yokutanga uye kuti Nguva yeRugare yakanzwisiswa zvisizvo: Maitiro Erai Akarasika

On Millenarianism - zvazviri, uye hazvisi 

Pamusoro pekuti "eschatology yekupererwa" yakakanganisa sei tariro yeChechi: Kufunga zvakare Nguva dzeKupera

Tsamba Yakavhurika kuna Baba Vatsvene panguva yeRunyararo: Vanodiwa Baba Vatsvene… Ivo Kuuya!

Pope Benedict pamusoro pekutarisira kwekuuya kwaKristu - Kuuya kweChipiri kusati kwasvika: The Pakati Kuuya

Kunzwisisa Kukunda Kwemoyo Wakachena: Kukunda - Zvikamu I-III

Pope John Paul II Kuuya kutsva uye hutsvene hwamwari

Hutsva hutsva… kana Nyonganiso Itsva?

Korona yehutsvene - kudzivirira kweNguva yeRunyararo uye Zvakazarurwa zvaJesu kuMuranda waMwari Luisa Piccarreta - naProfessor Daniel O'Connor (kana, kune imwe pfupiso pfupi yezvinyorwa zvakafanana, ona Korona Ye Nhoroondo).  

Bhuku idzva kubva kuna Daniel O'Connor: Kuda Kwako Ngakuitwe - Chikumbiro chikuru choMunyengetero Mukurusa—Baba Vedu—hachizoregi kupindurwa. Aya mazwi aKristu, “Kuda kwenyu ngakuitwe panyika sezvakunoitwa kudenga,” ndiwo akasimudzirwa zvikuru ati ambotaurwa; vanoronga mafambiro enhoroondo uye vanotsanangura basa remuKristu mumwe nemumwe. Kubva padzidziso dzeRugwaro neVatendi, kubva kuMadzibaba eChechi uye Vanachiremba, kubva kuMystics and Seers, kubva kuMagisterium nezvimwe-uchawana, mukati memapeji ebhuku rino, maitiro ekuita basa rechiKristu zvine simba kupfuura nakare kose, kuitira Shanduko huru yehupenyu hwako uye nekusvika kweWorld's Penultimate Destiny.

Kubwinya kweChisiko: Kukunda kweKuda kwaMwari Pasi uye Era yerunyararo mune zvakanyorwa zveMadzibaba Chechi, Vanachiremba uye Vangu naMufundisi Joseph Iannuzzi. 

Chipo cheKurarama muKuda kwaMwari mune Zvinyorwa zvaLuisa Piccarreta -Kubvunza mumakanzuru ekutanga ecumenical, uye patristic, scholastic uye yemazuva ano theology. —Zvak. Joseph Iannuzzi (ane Ecclesiastical Approbation kubva kuThe Pontifical Gregorian University yeRome, akatenderwa neHoly See)